Major League Baseball’s stuffed shirts treated the game’s all-time hit king like a leper, and the sports press cheered them on for decades.
Even his death didn’t settle the grudge.
And Donald Trump just signed one piece of paper that leaves the Cooperstown crowd out of excuses.
Charlie Hustle Finally Got a Win Out of Washington
President Donald Trump took to Truth Social and announced a posthumous pardon for Pete Rose, the scrappy Cincinnati Reds star who collected more hits than any player in the history of the big leagues.
“I have just given a Complete and Total Pardon to the Late, Great Pete Rose, a true Baseball SUPERSTAR & LEGEND, whose record of 4,256 Hits in a Season will never be broken,” Trump wrote.
Anybody who grew up listening to the Big Red Machine on the radio knows Rose piled up those hits over 24 seasons, not one. He passed Ty Cobb’s mark of 4,189 in 1985, in front of the home crowd in Cincinnati, and kept right on going.
And Mediaite pounced on the slip like a rookie umpire who finally got to toss somebody. The outlet rushed out a history lesson on Ichiro Suzuki’s 262 hits in 2004 and George Sisler’s 257 in 1920.
That’s the left-wing media in one snapshot. A President clears the record of a baseball legend, and the newsroom crowd fixates on one word in a social media post.
Trump’s post didn’t say which offense the pardon covered. But Rose only ever had one federal conviction. In 1990, he pleaded guilty to filing false income tax returns, and a federal judge sent him away for five months. He served the sentence at a federal prison in Marion, Illinois.
Prosecutors never charged Rose over his baseball bets. That punishment came from the league office alone.
Trump also went to bat for another old ace. Rose, he wrote, “just like the Great Roger Clemens, who won 354 games, was treated terribly by Major League Baseball in not allowing him to go into the Baseball Hall of Fame. Politics, I guess!”
A federal jury acquitted Clemens in 2012 of charges that he lied to Congress about steroids. And the Hall still won’t let him through the door either.
Trump Kept a Promise the Commissioners Ducked for Decades
None of this came out of nowhere. In March 2025, Trump told his followers, “Over the next few weeks I will be signing a complete pardon of Pete Rose, who shouldn’t have been gambling on baseball, but only bet on his team winning.”
It took longer than a few weeks. But Trump got it done, which is more than any commissioner managed between 1989 and the day Rose died.
Trump has carried this torch for years. Back in 2020 he posted that Rose “gambled, but only on his own team winning, and paid a decades long price.”
Here’s the short version of how Rose landed in exile. Commissioner A Bartlett Giamatti banned him for life in August 1989 after an investigation concluded Rose bet on baseball while managing the Reds. Rose denied it for 15 years before admitting in 2004 that he bet on games, though he swore he never bet against his own club.
Then Cooperstown piled on. In 1991, the Hall of Fame’s board adopted a rule barring anyone on baseball’s permanently ineligible list from its ballot. Sportswriters nicknamed it the Pete Rose Rule, and it kept him off every writers’ ballot from 1992 through 2006, the entire window when his numbers alone should have carried him in.
Rose died in 2024 at 83. Commissioner Rob Manfred finally pulled his name off the ineligible list in May 2025, roughly eight months later.
Funny how the league found its compassion only after Rose could no longer enjoy it.
The Investigator Who Hunted Rose Ended Up on Trump’s Legal Team
The man who ran MLB’s investigation of Rose was John Dowd. Years later, Dowd signed on as one of Trump’s personal attorneys.
In 2017, Dowd urged Trump to bring on a Washington lawyer named Ty Cobb, no relation to the Georgia Peach, as a White House attorney. Trump hired him. That Ty Cobb has since turned into a prominent Trump critic.
Baseball fans couldn’t script a stranger box score. The lawyer who built the case against Rose went to work for Trump, and a lawyer who shares a name with the legend Rose dethroned now spends his time bashing the President.
Baseball Banished Rose, Then Cozied Up to the Bookies
This part never makes the Cooperstown brochures. The league that treated Rose like a criminal for betting now cashes in through partnerships with licensed sportsbooks, and fans can wager on whether a single pitch lands for a ball or a strike.
And look where that got the game. Federal prosecutors in Brooklyn indicted Cleveland Guardians pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz in November 2025, accusing the pair of rigging individual pitches for gamblers. Prosecutors allege Clase helped his co-conspirator bettors win at least $400,000. Ortiz’s lawyer disputed the indictment’s findings.
MLB’s answer? The league announced its authorized sportsbook partners agreed to cap wagers on individual pitches at $200.
A $200 cap. The bookies still get their action.
But Rose, who insisted he only ever bet on his own team to win, sat outside the gates for 36 years. Something doesn’t add up there.
Politics crept into the league office long before Trump’s post, too. In 2021, Manfred yanked the All-Star Game out of Atlanta after Democrats howled about Georgia’s new election integrity law, and Joe Biden publicly backed moving the game. So when Trump signed off with “Politics, I guess!” he had a pretty thick file to draw from.
A Pardon the Biden Crowd Has No Business Lecturing About
Expect the usual voices to sniff at pardoning a dead ballplayer. But they’ve got a credibility problem.
In June 2024, Biden told reporters, “I abide by the jury decision. I will do that and I will not pardon him.” He pardoned Hunter in December 2024 anyway. On his way out the door in January 2025, Biden handed preemptive pardons to his own brothers and sister, plus Anthony Fauci, Mark Milley, and members of the January 6 committee.
Trump pardoned a man who served his time, paid his debt, and died still waiting on baseball. Biden pardoned his own family before any prosecutor could ask a single question.
What Happens When Cooperstown’s Committee Meets
The real test comes in December 2027, when the Hall’s Classic Baseball Era Committee convenes. A 10-person historical overview panel picks an eight-name ballot first, and Rose still has to make that cut.
From there, 16 committee members vote, and a candidate needs 12 to get in. Hall of Famers, team executives, and media members fill those seats.
That same kind of committee shut out Clemens and Barry Bonds in 2022. Neither man got even four votes.
Maybe a pardon changes nothing inside that room. A presidential signature can’t cast a Hall of Fame ballot. But it does forgive the one federal conviction on Rose’s record, and it takes away the last bit of cover a voter could hide behind.
Rose won three batting titles, the 1973 National League MVP, and World Series rings with the Reds in 1975 and 1976 and the Phillies in 1980. And nobody on that committee will need a refresher on the numbers.
If the committee says yes, Rose’s plaque goes up in Cooperstown no earlier than the summer of 2028, almost 39 years after Giamatti signed the ban and four years after Rose died waiting.
Sources: Mediaite, “Trump Credits Pete Rose With Impossible Record: ‘Will Never Be Broken’”; CBS News, “Trump says he’s pardoned deceased MLB slugger Pete Rose”; NBC News, “Trump says he will posthumously pardon baseball legend Pete Rose”; Deadline, Trump posthumous pardon coverage (2020 post); NBC Sports/Associated Press, “MLB reinstates Pete Rose and Shoeless Joe Jackson, making them Hall of Fame eligible”; MLB.com, Hall of Fame statement on MLB permanent ineligibility decision; ESPN, “Everything to know about MLB lifting ban on Pete Rose”; The Philadelphia Inquirer, “Pete Rose is now eligible for the Hall of Fame”; WJLA, Pete Rose removed from permanently ineligible list; ESPN, “Guardians’ Emmanuel Clase, Luis Ortiz indicted for pitch rigging”; ESPN, “What we know about the Clase-Ortiz pitch-rigging indictments”; NPR, “MLB pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz charged with taking bribes to rig pitches”
Stay connected