Fresh off a midterm wipeout, Elon Musk told a liberal newspaper’s audience he isn’t MAGA after all.
The giddy Left and one washed-up Never-Trumper lapped it up like free champagne.
And Donald Trump just answered from Air Force One with a sentence Musk would be wise to frame.
Elon Musk Picked a Strange Stage for His Declaration of Independence
Musk beamed into The New York Times’ DealBook Summit from Shenzhen, China, where he had tagged along with the President’s delegation. Then he handed Andrew Ross Sorkin the soundbite the Times crowd had waited two years to hear.
“I’m not MAGA,” Musk said.
He tried to explain himself, and it didn’t go much better. “I’m not sure what MAGA means,” he told Sorkin, adding that “if it means sort of blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party, then I certainly don’t have that.”
Next came the self-portrait. Musk called himself “ideologically quite moderate” and claimed he holds no extreme political views. He even predicted that Texas’ incoming Democrat governor, Gina Hinojosa, will govern as a moderate, which is a generous forecast for a woman who hasn’t signed a single bill yet.
That’s a long way from the October 2024 rally where Musk bounced around the stage in a black cap and told the crowd, “I’m not just MAGA, I’m dark MAGA.”
Musk also opened up about his checkbook. He poured roughly $446 million into the midterms, bankrolling super PACs behind House and Senate Republicans, including more than $150 million to a group backing Ken Paxton’s Senate bid. Paxton fell to Democrat state Representative James Talarico, and Democrats took control of both chambers of Congress.
“Obviously, the Republicans were routed in this election and . . . I feel pretty foolish about having spent so much money and not seeing much for it,” Musk said.
He wasn’t done. “Probably if I could rewind the clock, I would have spent less money,” he added.
Donald Trump Kept It Friendly and Still Left a Mark
Trump didn’t take the bait the press dangled in front of him.
Flying home from his Asia trip, he phoned NBC News and called Musk “a friend of mine.” He pointed out that Musk traveled with him for the whole swing and said “Elon’s got very good intentions.”
But Trump didn’t let the “I’m not sure what MAGA means” line slide, either.
“There are lots of definitions out there. MAGA, to me, means something very specific, and when people veer from it, they don’t do very well,” Trump said.
Read that one slowly. Trump didn’t threaten anybody, and he didn’t cut Musk loose. He simply reminded the richest man on Earth that the movement has a fixed address, and that folks who wander off tend to find the road gets bumpy in a hurry.
The liberal press wanted a nasty public divorce with lawyers and screaming. It got a friendly phone call with a warning label stapled to it.
Jeff Flake Rushed In to Rewrite the Definition
The Never Trump crowd couldn’t resist the opening.
Former US Senator Jeff Flake (R-AZ), who walked away from his seat in 2018 instead of facing Arizona’s Republican primary voters and later took Joe Biden’s appointment as ambassador to Turkey, went on CNN to explain what MAGA supposedly means.
“MAGA is not blind adherence to a set of principles,” Flake told host Erin Burnett, “it’s blind adherence to one individual.”
That’s the same cartoon the Left has drawn since 2016, a cult of personality with no ideas underneath. It’s a handy cartoon, too. Nobody on CNN ever has to argue with the ideas if the ideas don’t exist.
And Trump’s answer knocked the cartoon flat. He didn’t say MAGA means loyalty to Donald Trump. He said it means “something very specific.”
So what is it?
Ask the voters who built the movement and the list comes out fast. Secure the border and deport illegal aliens. Put American workers ahead of cheap foreign labor. Use tariffs to drag factories home from Communist China. Quit shipping American kids and American tax dollars into endless foreign wars. Stand up to the Big Tech censors and the bureaucrats who turned the government against ordinary people.
Nothing blind about any of it. Those positions put Trump on a collision course with the donor class in both parties, and the folks who voted for them knew exactly what they were buying.
Musk Already Showed Exactly Where He Veers
Here’s the part Musk’s fans won’t enjoy. The DealBook confession didn’t fall out of a clear blue sky.
Over Christmas 2024, before Trump even took the oath, Musk picked a fight with longtime MAGA supporters over the H-1B visa program that lets tech companies import foreign workers. He told critics, “I will go to war on this issue the likes of which you cannot possibly comprehend.”
War. Over foreign tech workers. Against his own side.
Trump eventually settled the H-1B question his way. In September 2025, he slapped a $100,000 fee on new H-1B petitions, a direct shot at companies that treat the visa as a discount pipeline for replacing American engineers.
Then came the 2025 blowup over the One Big Beautiful Bill. Musk trashed the President’s signature law, and on July 5, 2025, he announced the America Party, a project he had pitched as a home for “the 80 percent in the middle.”
“Today, the America Party is formed to give you back your freedom,” Musk wrote.
Sound familiar? “The 80 percent in the middle” in 2025 turned into “ideologically quite moderate” in 2026. Same song, new verse.
Maybe Musk only means he disagrees with Republicans on spending, which plenty of conservatives do. Maybe. But a man who vows war over foreign worker visas and then shops a centrist third party has already told everybody where he stands on the question the America First base cares about most, which is who gets the jobs.
The Record Behind Trump’s Warning
Trump’s “they don’t do very well” line isn’t bluster. The scoreboard backs him up.
Flake’s Senate career ended once he turned his fire on the Republican base. Former US Representative Liz Cheney (R-WY) crossed MAGA voters and lost her own primary in 2022 by more than 30 points.
And the midterm rout Musk keeps moaning about tells the same story from the other direction. When NBC News exit pollsters asked whether taking military action against Iran was the right call, “wrong” beat “right” 63 to 37, and Democrats scooped up 83 percent of the wrong-call voters. The neoconservatives who pushed Trump toward that fight wanted the party to drift from its no-more-endless-wars promise. Republicans paid the bill at the ballot box.
But Musk didn’t draw that lesson. He drew the opposite one, deciding the problem must be MAGA itself.
Now Texas has a Democrat governor and a Democrat senator for the first time in decades, in a state reshaped by nation-changing immigration levels, and Musk is out there vouching for the newcomers before they’ve done a thing. Democrats holding both chambers of Congress have already promised to haul him in for questioning anyway. The “moderate” pose won’t buy him a single favor from people who see socialism as the destination and the gavel as the vehicle.
Trump, for his part, left the door open. Friends can disagree. Musk can still ride along on the next trip.
But the movement doesn’t answer to a checkbook, and it never did.
Sixteen months after he launched a party for “the 80 percent in the middle,” Elon Musk wrote nearly half a billion dollars in checks to elect Republicans, then told a New York Times audience he was never really one of them.
Sources: New York Post, “Trump sends pointed message to Elon Musk after trillionaire claims he’s ‘not MAGA’”; Axios, “Trump calls Elon Musk a friend despite billionaire saying he’s ‘not MAGA’”; NBC News, “Elon Musk says he is ‘not MAGA’ after spending millions on Trump and his allies”; The Daily Beast, “Musk Ripped by Republican After MAGA U-Turn”; Gizmodo, “Trump Responds to Elon Musk Saying He’s Not MAGA”; Fortune, Axios, and Al Jazeera on the December 2024 H-1B dispute; Gizmodo, NPR, and Yahoo News on the July 2025 America Party announcement; NBC News 2026 exit polling
Stay connected