Donald Trump wants a Democrat Senate candidate yanked off the ballot and hauled into court.
Her party’s top Senate campaign boss calls the whole uproar a pretext to throw out Democrat wins.
And Chris Murphy just floated one hypothetical that gave away far more than he meant to.
Trump Wants Two Names Gone Before Anybody Counts a Vote
President Donald Trump stopped for reporters at Joint Base Andrews in late October 2026 and unloaded on former Congresswoman Mary Peltola (D-AK), the Democrat challenging US Senator Dan Sullivan (R-AK).
His target was the second Dan Sullivan on the ballot, a man named Dan J Sullivan, along with a New York Times report that tied Peltola’s camp to his candidacy.
“They created a fake candidate,” Trump said. “They took a candidate named Dan Sullivan to run against another candidate who’s a great senator named Dan Sullivan in order to cheat in the election.”
He didn’t stop there. Trump said Peltola should drop out and face criminal prosecution, and he wants the same for the other Sullivan. He laid out his remedy in two steps: “number one, they should be taken off the ballot. And number two, they should be prosecuted.”
And he zeroed in on the problem every voter in that booth will face. “They had two Dan Sullivans. The people aren’t going to be able to tell.”
What the Times Says Peltola’s Allies Cooked Up
According to the Times, which ABC News says leaned on 12 sources plus text messages and documents, people working with Peltola’s campaign and senior aides at the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee helped push Dan J Sullivan into the race. Insiders allegedly called the effort the “ballot composition project.”
Fox News’ rundown of the report adds a few eyebrow-raisers. The Times says one operative traveled the state under assumed names, and advisers kicked around a third-party “MAGA party” to peel votes off the senator before scrapping the idea in May.
Peltola’s former campaign manager, Elisa Rios, told the paper that Peltola didn’t run the project herself but was “definitely aware” of it. Peltola fired Rios in August.
The denials haven’t budged. “The Alaskans for Mary campaign has no involvement with either Sullivan campaign and did not recruit any candidates into the race,” the Peltola campaign told the Times. The DSCC insists it had no role either.
Dan J Sullivan told voters back in June that his contact with Peltola’s operation amounted to “Zero, none, zilch.” Nobody involved faces any charges.
Peltola waved the story off as a “distraction,” according to the Associated Press, and steered the talk toward her opponent’s record on Iran. Senator Sullivan’s campaign had a sharper read: “Mary Peltola, her campaign and her senior advisers colluded with the DSCC, national Democrat lawyers and Alaska Democrat operatives to recruit candidates to deliberately confuse and deceive voters.”
Chris Murphy Answered His Own Question
Enter Senator Chris Murphy (D-CT), who runs the DSCC. That’s the same committee whose senior aides the Times places inside the operation, so Murphy didn’t exactly show up on CNN as a neutral character witness.
He opened with something close to a confession. “I don’t I don’t know the whole story here,” Murphy told Kaitlan Collins.
But he vouched for Peltola anyway. “I trust the Peltola campaign that they didn’t have anything to do with it,” he said, before accusing Trump of hunting for an excuse to wipe out Democrat victories.
Collins kept pressing. “I mean, would you like it if another Chris Murphy ran on the ballot?”
Murphy’s answer deserves a frame on the wall. “I wouldn’t have any worry if the ballot in Connecticut said incumbent Senator Chris Murphy, I would trust that everybody who wants to vote for me is going to vote for me.”
Read it one more time. Murphy’s whole safety net is a label, the word “incumbent” and the title “Senator” sitting right next to his name.
According to Trump, Alaska’s ballot offers no such thing for the real Sullivan. “And they didn’t put Senator in front,” the President said. CNBC reports the other man shows up simply as “Sullivan, Dan.”
So the DSCC chairman’s comfort depends on a cue that Alaska voters, by Trump’s account, won’t get. Take the label away and Murphy never says what happens next.
Democrats Sang a Different Tune About Confused Voters in 2024
Here’s where the story gets awkward for the Peltola crowd.
In September 2024, the Alaska Democratic Party rushed to court to knock Eric Hafner off the US House ballot. Hafner, a Democrat, is serving a 20-year sentence in a New York prison for threatening public officials in New Jersey. Peltola, then the incumbent, faced a close fight with Republican Nick Begich.
Democrats worried Hafner could siphon votes from Peltola. According to the Alaska Beacon, party attorneys told the Alaska Supreme Court that some voters could get confused by two Democrats on one ballot.
The case mostly turned on a dry question about filling slots left by candidates who withdrew. Anchorage Superior Court Judge Ian Wheeles brushed aside the confusion worry, noting that ranked-choice voters can list several picks. The high court sided with him 4-1.
But the Democrats’ complaint stuck around. Party chair Mike Wenstrup said the ruling “sets a dangerous precedent and is embarrassing for our state.”
So when one stray name threatened Peltola, confused voters counted as a danger worth an emergency appeal. Now a near-twin of her opponent sits on the ballot, allegedly with help from her own allies, and the same worry turns into a Trump pretext.
The Pretext Charge Runs Into the Calendar
Murphy’s claim that Trump wants an excuse to overturn results skips over what the administration has actually put on paper.
Attorney General Todd Blanche says that, if necessary, the Justice Department wants a “full judicial process” to figure out what went wrong before Alaska certifies anything. That’s a request for a judge, not a decree from the Oval Office.
John Yoo, the former Deputy Assistant Attorney General, went further on Fox News. Yoo said investigators should look at Peltola’s campaign, the DSCC, and affiliated PACs over the alleged spoiler recruitment, and he raised the prospect of obstruction of justice charges.
And that’s the legal stake hiding underneath the political one. Trump said the Democrats “went to court” and claimed to know nothing. Recruiting a candidate may or may not break any law, but denials made in a courtroom carry consequences of their own if they turn out false. Courts haven’t sorted any of that out yet.
The numbers explain why everybody’s sweating. Dan J Sullivan pulled about 2.5% in the August primary, and a CNN-reported poll shows Peltola ahead by seven points among likely voters. In a race like that, a slice of mixed-up ballots can matter a great deal.
Maybe the polls hold and none of it ends up mattering. Maybe. But millions of Americans heard Democrats spend four years insisting that every question about election integrity was a fever dream, and this time the evidence came from the New York Times, not a Republican lawyer.
So when Democrat lawyers stand up in Trump’s lawsuit and swear no Alaskan could ever mix up two Dan Sullivans, will anybody remind them what their own party told the state’s highest court about one imprisoned Democrat two years ago?
Sources: RealClearPolitics, “Trump: Peltola and ‘The Fake Dan Sullivan’ Should Be Taken Off The Ballot And Prosecuted”; RealClearPolitics/Yahoo News, “Sen. Murphy: I Trust The Peltola Campaign, Trump Looking For A Pretext To Invalidate Democratic Victories”; RealClearPolitics, “John Yoo: Peltola Campaign’s Alleged Election Scheme Could Lead To Obstruction Of Justice Charges” and “AG Blanche: If Necessary, We Want A ‘Full Judicial Process’”; CNBC, “Peltola campaign aides, DSCC officials helped recruit second Dan Sullivan in Alaska race: NYT”; ABC News, “Peltola campaign under fire after report that it recruited second Dan Sullivan”; Fox News, report on the “ballot composition project”; PBS NewsHour/Associated Press, “Trump calls for prosecution of Alaska Senate candidate Peltola”; CNN, “Democrats were reportedly behind the other Dan Sullivan”; Alaska Beacon via Juneau Empire, “Alaska Supreme Court rejects Democrats’ attempt to remove candidate from U.S. House ballot” (September 2024)
Stay connected