Federal agents haven’t finished the job they started at Ilhan Omar’s door, and her allies call it a political hit.
Newsrooms want a judge to throw the file open before Election Day.
And Donald Trump settled this exact fight years ago in a way Omar never has.
Prosecutors Told the Judge Their Search Isn’t Finished
The Justice Department handed the federal courthouse in Washington, DC a surprise that Ilhan Omar’s defenders probably didn’t see coming.
The search warrant for her home isn’t done.
In a redacted 47-page filing, prosecutors told the court that the warrant remains only partially executed and reaches “other individuals” beyond the congresswoman herself. They added that “the United States expects that the warrant will be fully executed in short order.”
Homeland Security Investigations agents searched the Washington home of Representative Ilhan Omar (D-MN) at about 6:05 a.m. on October 12. A person familiar with the case told Reuters that the warrant lists conspiracy, false statements, and immigration fraud as possible crimes. Prosecutors have also sent grand jury subpoenas to members of her family.
Omar faces no charges. She denies any wrongdoing, and her attorney has called the investigation “politically motivated.” Critics have alleged for years that her former husband, Ahmed Nur Said Elmi, is actually her brother. Omar has always denied it, and no court has ever found the claim true.
Attorney General Todd Blanche personally signed off on the warrant. According to the filing, he confirmed that its timing did not have “the purpose of affecting any election” or “of giving an advantage or disadvantage to any candidate or political party.”
Prosecutors also warned the judge that the sworn affidavit behind the search is “chock full of privacy interests.” And they asked for a heads-up before any unsealing order takes effect, a strong hint that they would race to an appeals court for an emergency freeze.
A Wall of Newsrooms Wants the Whole File Right Now
The push to open those records comes from a heavyweight lineup. Fourteen news organizations, including ABC News, the Associated Press, Bloomberg, Dow Jones, NBCUniversal, Politico, Reuters, USA Today, and the Washington Post, filed a joint request. The New York Times filed its own. The conservative watchdog Judicial Watch filed a third.
All three requests landed on the desk of Chief Judge James Boasberg.
The Times’ lawyers didn’t bother hiding their impatience when prosecutors first said agents still had work left. “We are also perplexed regarding what ‘execution’ you refer to,” they wrote.
Well, now they know. Other individuals.
That phrase changes the whole argument. A sealed affidavit protects more than the person whose name sits at the top of the warrant. It also protects the next door agents plan to knock on. Throw the file open early, and anybody still on that list gets a free preview of what the government knows.
But Washington has watched this exact standoff play out before. The only difference is the name on the folder.
Merrick Garland Wrote the Secrecy Playbook First
On August 8, 2022, FBI agents searched Mar-a-Lago, Donald Trump’s home in Palm Beach. Attorney General Merrick Garland told reporters he “personally approved” the decision to seek the warrant.
Nearly the same roster of news outlets, including the AP, NBC News, and ABC News, then asked Magistrate Judge Bruce Reinhart to unseal the affidavit. “You can’t trust what you can’t see,” Chuck Tobin, a lawyer for the AP and other outlets, told the court.
Garland’s Justice Department fought them every step. Prosecutors called the affidavit a roadmap to their investigation and warned that releasing it “would also likely chill future cooperation by witnesses.”
Sound familiar? Todd Blanche’s team now makes almost the identical case about Omar. Funny how the secrecy argument sounded like responsible law enforcement when Garland’s lawyers made it, and only started smelling like a cover-up once the shoe landed on the other foot.
And here’s the part nobody in the Omar camp seems eager to discuss.
Donald Trump didn’t hide behind the seal. He did the exact opposite. On August 15, 2022, he posted on Truth Social: “In the interest of TRANSPARENCY, I call for the immediate release of the completely Unredacted Affidavit pertaining to this horrible and shocking BREAK-IN.”
Completely unredacted. Every line, every name. Reinhart released a heavily blacked-out version later that month, and Trump wanted more of it out, not less.
Omar Fires Off Angry Letters but Goes Quiet on the Seal
Omar’s legal team hasn’t exactly sat on its hands. In an October letter to prosecutors, her lawyers demanded the return of everything agents carried out of the house. “This search was neither justified nor lawful,” they wrote. They added, “The political motivations behind this pre-election investigation and search are clear as day.”
They even asked for records from a 2019 look into her immigration history.
But on the one question of whether the public should read the government’s evidence, the record goes oddly quiet. In its own filing, the Justice Department told Boasberg that “[Omar] may very well wish to keep these materials under seal. It is unknown what her position is.”
Think about that for a second. A congresswoman in the middle of a reelection campaign insists the whole case is a political hit job. And nothing in the public reporting shows her lawyers demanding the one document that could prove it.
If the affidavit really holds nothing but partisan fumes, she has every reason to want voters reading it before the November 3 election.
Maybe her lawyers worry about her relatives. The New York Times reported that text messages among family members helped persuade a judge to approve the search, and investigators seized a phone belonging to her sister, Sahra Noor, before agents ever reached the congresswoman’s door. A full release could drag family members into the spotlight.
Maybe so. But Trump’s family called Mar-a-Lago home too, and he still told the whole country to read every word.
The Judge Conservatives Trust Least Now Holds the Key
The irony keeps stacking up like firewood. Boasberg, an Obama appointee, clashed with the Trump administration in March 2025 when he tried to halt deportation flights to El Salvador, and Trump called for his impeachment. US Senator Chuck Grassley (R-IA) later revealed that Boasberg signed nondisclosure orders that kept Republican senators in the dark after the Biden-era FBI collected their phone records.
That same judge now decides whether the “other individuals” in an immigration fraud probe get a look at the government’s cards before agents finish their work. He already let prosecutors explain their reasoning in a sealed memo that only he can read.
But the press coalition isn’t backing off. These outlets want the affidavit, the application, the sealing orders, and the warrant return, all of it, and they want it before voters cast a ballot.
Most retired folks who’ve sat on a jury or served on a church board understand the basic idea. Nobody hands the other side the playbook in the middle of the game.
And nobody has asked the obvious follow-up. If the Omar file stays sealed through Election Day, the same newsrooms that accepted Garland’s roadmap argument will call it a scandal. If it opens early, the people on that list of other individuals will read it right alongside everyone else.
Donald Trump once demanded that a judge show the country every word the government wrote about him. Ilhan Omar’s lawyers have filled their letters with complaints about the search, and the Justice Department still can’t tell a judge whether she wants anybody reading the reasons for it.
Sources: Newsweek, “DOJ says Ilhan Omar warrant ongoing, targets other individuals”; Raw Story, “Judge demands answers on Ilhan Omar raid after DOJ says it’s not ‘fully executed’ yet” and “DOJ begs judge to hide Dem raid warrant that’s not ‘fully executed’ until after midterms”; The Digital Free Press, “News Outlets, The New York Times and Judicial Watch Ask Judge to Unseal Search Warrant”; Newsmax via Yahoo News, “Dershowitz to Newsmax: Omar in ‘Much Deeper Trouble’”; The Daily Wire, “DOJ Reveals Feds Still Have Unfinished Business in Ilhan Omar Raid”; Al Jazeera, “Ilhan Omar’s lawyers demand the return of property seized in house raid”; ABC News via AOL, “DOJ opposes news media request to unseal Trump search affidavit, calls it ‘roadmap’ to criminal investigation”; Toronto Star via PressReader, “Judge may unseal part of FBI affidavit”; NPR, “Justice Dept. Files Motion To Unseal Mar-a-Lago Search Warrant”; National Review, “DOJ Releases Mar-a-Lago Search Affidavit”
Stay connected